A Primer on the Distinction between Justification and Excuse
نویسنده
چکیده
This article is about the distinction between justification and excuse, a distinction which, while familiar, remains controversial. My discussion focuses on three questions. First, what is the distinction? Second, why is it important? And third, what are some areas of inquiry in which the distinction might be philosophically fruitful? I suggest that the distinction has practical and theoretical consequences, and is therefore worth taking seriously; I highlight two philosophical issues in which the distinction might play a useful role; but I express skepticism about the prospects for drawing a firm distinction between justification and excuse.
منابع مشابه
Criminal Justice Ethics
Suppose Alice hits Bert on the head. Prima facie, Alice has done something that she ought not to have done: in hitting Bert she has harmed him, or violated a right of his not to be hit on the head, or interfered with his ability to determine his own ends.2 And yet it may be that Alice should not be punished for hitting Bert, either because her action is justified, or because she is excused. It ...
متن کاملDenial of Responsibility and Normative Negation
In this paper I provide some linguistic evidence to the thesis that responsibility judgments are normative. I present an argument from negation, since the negation of descriptive judgments is structurally different from the negation of normative judgments. In particular, the negation of responsibility judgments seem to conform to the pattern of the negation of normative judgments, thus being a ...
متن کاملRules of Conduct and Principles of Adjudication
I. Rules of Conduct and Principles of Adjudication: The Distinction and Its Implications .............. 730 II. Rules of Conduct and Principles of Adjudication in Current Doctrine ................................ 733 A. The Distinction Applied to Current Doctrine.. 733 1. Objective elements of an offense .......... 733 2. Secondary prohibitions .................. 734 3. State of mind elements ....
متن کاملبررسی رابطه کمال گرایی بهنجار و نوروتیک با خودناتوان سازی و زیر مقیاس های آن در دانشجویان پسر
Aim: The present research was aimed to determine the relationship between normal and neurotic perfectionism, and self-handicapping and its subscales (negative mood, effort, and excuse-making) among male university students. Method: The method of the current research was descriptive-correlational. Total of 350 male post-graduate students from University of Tehran were selected by cluster samplin...
متن کاملInvestigating the Effect of Constructing Social Accounts on Accountants' Unethical Behavior: With Mediating Role of Moral Disengagement and Guilt
According to importance of the issue of ethic in Islam, the purpose of this research is to investigate the negative dimensions of social accounting and how it affects the ethical behavior of accountants. This is an applied research and uses structural equation modeling. Due to the wide scope of the study population, using a Cochran formula, a sample of 384 students and accounting professionals ...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
دوره شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2009